In the dynamic world of One Day International (ODI) cricket, where batting positions can dictate fortunes, a fervent debate has reignited following KL Rahul’s stellar century against New Zealand. Former India batter Dodda Ganesh has issued a strong, almost cautionary, appeal to the team management: cement KL Rahul’s spot at number five, or risk committing a ‘cardinal sin’. This breaking news analysis delves into Ganesh’s impassioned plea and the compelling statistics that underscore Rahul’s invaluable contribution to the Indian middle-order.

The ‘Cardinal Sin’ Warning: Dodda Ganesh’s Advocacy for KL Rahul

The catalyst for this renewed discussion was KL Rahul’s magnificent unbeaten 112 runs off just 92 balls during India’s second ODI against New Zealand in Rajkot. Following a crucial 29 not out in the first game, Rahul’s century, adorned with 11 fours and one six, solidified his credentials as a formidable force in the middle overs.

Dodda Ganesh, a former India international, wasted no time in articulating his conviction. Taking to X, he wrote, ‘Kannur Lokesh Rahul! This is what he can do at no 5 in the ODIs. For heaven’s sake, please let him bat there.‘ His plea didn’t stop there. Ganesh vehemently argued against pushing Rahul down the order, specifically below all-rounders Axar Patel or Ravindra Jadeja. ‘Pushing him to No.6, below Axar Patel or Ravindra Jadeja, is going to be a cardinal sin,‘ he asserted, adding, ‘This is why I was always harping about having KL Rahul at no 5, in the ODIs. KL knows to pace the inns well, and has all the shots in his armoury to go all-out in the death. Pushing him to no 6, below Axar/Jadeja, is going to be a cardinal sin. KL is Rolls-Royce. Use him.‘ Such strong language from an ex-pro highlights the gravity of the decision for the team management.

KL Rahul’s Imperious Form: A Statistical Deep Dive

Ganesh’s advocacy isn’t based purely on sentiment; it’s backed by Rahul’s undeniable statistical prowess, particularly from the number five position. Rahul’s eighth ODI ton serves as a timely reminder of his adaptability and class. Entering the crease when India were three wickets down for 115, and soon witnessing the departure of Virat Kohli, Rahul anchored the innings for nearly 30 overs, showcasing both resilience and explosive power.

Master of the Middle Order: Number Five Dominance

At number five, KL Rahul has truly carved a niche for himself as a ‘masterful accumulator’. His record in this position is exceptional:

• Matches: 33 innings
• Runs: 1,477
• Average: 64.21
• Strike Rate: 99.59
• Centuries: 3
• Fifties: 10

These figures place him among the elite middle-order batsmen in contemporary ODI cricket. An average north of 60, coupled with a strike rate nearing 100, demonstrates his ability to not only stabilize the innings but also accelerate when required. He is the crucial bridge between a potentially faltering top order and the explosive death-overs finish.

Versatility as a Finisher: The Number Six Role

While his prowess at number five is clear, Rahul has also showcased his finishing capabilities from the number six position. In 12 innings batting at number six, he has scored 332 runs at an average of 47.42, with a strike rate of 99.10 and one fifty. This versatility, as highlighted by Ganesh, allows him to ‘either finish the game or not let the game finish for India’.

The Quicker Gear: Death Overs Acceleration

Perhaps most impressively, Rahul has found a ‘quicker gear and tempo in ODIs’ since 2025. Batting primarily in the middle-order, he has scored 283 runs from overs 41-50 at an astounding strike rate of 140.09. This places his run count as the best globally and his strike rate as the fourth-best in this period, trailing only Justin Greaves, Glenn Phillips, and Janith Liyanage. His innings against New Zealand perfectly illustrated this: starting at 52 runs off 53 balls (SR > 98) by the 41st over, he smashed 60 runs off his next 39 balls (SR > 153) to complete his century.

Expert Analysis: Why No. 5 is KL Rahul’s Sanctuary

Dodda Ganesh’s argument against placing Rahul below Axar Patel or Ravindra Jadeja stems from a deep understanding of ODI team dynamics. While Axar and Jadeja are exceptional all-rounders, providing vital balance with their spin bowling and capable batting, their primary role is often skewed towards their bowling contributions. Rahul, on the other hand, is a specialist top-order batter who has successfully transitioned to the middle order, bringing a different dimension.

Strategic Importance of Number Five

The number five position in ODIs is arguably one of the most demanding. It requires a player who can rebuild an innings after a collapse, accelerate against both pace and spin, and guide the team through the middle overs into a strong finish. This role demands a blend of temperament, shot-making ability, and game awareness – qualities KL Rahul has consistently displayed. His ability to ‘pace the inns well’ and ‘go all-out in the death’ makes him a complete package for this crucial slot.

The Dilemma of All-Rounders vs. Specialist Batters

Pushing a ‘Rolls-Royce’ like Rahul, who has such a dominant record at number five, below Axar or Jadeja suggests a strategic choice that might prioritize bowling depth over optimal batting firepower. While having capable batters like Axar and Jadeja lower down the order adds solidity, sacrificing a proven number five specialist for this could disrupt the batting rhythm and potentially leave the team vulnerable in scenarios requiring a sustained batting effort through the middle overs. It’s a delicate balance, but Ganesh’s argument leans heavily on maximizing Rahul’s core batting strength where it yields the greatest impact.

Impact on Team Balance and Future Tournaments

The consistency and versatility offered by KL Rahul at number five are invaluable, especially as India looks towards major ICC tournaments. A stable middle order allows the top order to play more freely and provides a cushion against early wickets. Rahul’s ability to seamlessly switch between accumulation and aggression offers the captain strategic flexibility, which is gold in high-pressure matches. His recent form, where he has scored 508 runs in 16 matches (13 innings) since last year (mostly at six and three times at five) at an average of 72.57 and a strike rate of over 112, only strengthens the case for his fixed role.

Conclusion: A Plea for Consistency and Strategic Acumen

Dodda Ganesh’s impassioned plea resonates with the statistical evidence of KL Rahul’s success at number five. His ‘cardinal sin’ warning is not merely an emotional outburst but a strategic insight rooted in cricket sense. Rahul’s impressive century against New Zealand is a testament to his capabilities, showcasing why he is a ‘Rolls-Royce’ for the Indian ODI team in the middle order. As the team management navigates team compositions and batting orders, the call to ‘let him bat there’ at number five is a compelling argument for maximizing one of India’s most versatile and impactful white-ball cricketers. Ignoring such a clear statistical and performance-based argument, particularly from a player who has evolved into such a critical middle-order lynchpin, could indeed prove to be a significant strategic misstep.

---

Disclaimer: Cricket Mantra aggregates breaking cricket news from multiple reputable sources, enriching them with in-depth analysis and expert commentary to provide comprehensive coverage for our readers.